Would you believe that both of the above yarns have the same fibre content (cotton) AND have the same number of yards per pound?
Well, they do.
But that's the thing about assumptions. They will trip us up at times.
I made an assumption about an issue another weaver was having and I assumed wrong. When they told me that I was 'wrong', I apologized, because based on my incorrect assumption, I was giving them inappropriate advice in answer to the question and what they needed to know.
Because that's the thing about weaving - change one thing and everything can change.
I tend to stay out of most conversations online, especially if I see that a question has been answered a multitude of times.
Sometimes it's a person with a 'floor' loom asking why something is happening and a rigid heddle weaver will answer, not realizing that when you scale up (or down), things can get very different in terms of techniques and even tools, that work 'better' than others.
Someone will ask a question about a rug they are making, and people with zero experience making a rug will answer, not realizing that at times, making a rug can look quite different from making a silk scarf.
Sometimes a weaver will assume that they know everything there is to know about a particular size of yarn and assume all yarns of that count are identical in nature. Like the two yarns above.
To learn all the 'it depends' factors in the creation of cloth takes years and exposure to many different options - both yarn and loom.
Like the assumption by so many that every loom *requires* a shuttle race. (nope.) Like the assumption by many that a counter balanced loom 'can't' weave an unbalanced weave structure. While roller type counter balanced looms don't much like doing it, they can. A counter balanced loom using pulleys or levers can do anything you want them to do, sometimes way better than a jack or rising shed loom.
So when I see inappropriate levels of advice being given, I tend to quietly slip out of the group and curb my tendency to teach people the multitudes of way weaving is complex and how much it depends is part of that complexity. For one thing, it requires more than a very short answer ('it depends' is short but not very helpful!) and Facebook isn't usually compatible with long form responses.
And rather than single out someone, I prefer to approach the concept more generally and post the information here.
A lot of these online groups don't allow 'marketing' so I don't even feel able to share information about this blog, or my books and classes, lest I be accused of marketing on the group.
This week I was contacted again by WEFT to contribute an article for issue 7. So far I am contracted for every issue of the magazine (I'm not the only one, lots of good weaving/teachers are represented!) I honestly don't know how long they will want me to write for them, but really? It is keeping me getting up and to the loom pretty much every day (or to the studio, at least).
For all the abuse I put my body through being a production weaver, the craft is sustaining me now.
And no, I don't know 'everything'. Not even close. I know just enough to be 'dangerous' about other types of cloth than my 'usual'. I know enough to admire a 'good' rug, or tapestry, or narrow goods. Not that I particularly want to weave those, but I know what a good textile looks like in those categories.
I can admire the wonderful work that is being done by weavers exploring the potential of Jacquard and drawloom designing. I'm no longer envious of those weavers. But again, I know enough to admire those who are doing it.
And bottom line? Yes, things go pear shaped for me, too. I had an issue with the loom, which I *thought* I had fixed, but when I cut, serged and inspected the 7 towels, I discovered that 5 of the 7 had treadling 'errors' due to a random shaft lifting when it shouldn't. I could not see the problem on the side that was facing me, but when I turned the web over, the long floats stood out like a freeway across a flood plain.
Not everyone needs to dig into the craft as deeply as I have. But realize that some people are so wedded to their own 'reality' that they will not understand the issues that someone else might be having.
And if you see me post a response and you feel I'm not understanding the situation, please let me know. Or if you want to hear more, you can contact me. Or recommend my books/classes - because in too many groups, I'm not allowed to tell people myself.
...the craft so long to learn...